Here for every stage of your life. (855) 436-6552
Partners for Life — Insurance Agency & Financial Services
← Back to articles

Indexed Universal Life Insurance: Pros and Cons

Is an IUL Policy Right for You?

What Is Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL)?

Indexed universal life insurance (IUL) policies can help you build wealth while leaving a death benefit for your loved ones. These policies allocate a portion of the policyholder's premium payments to annual renewable term life insurance, with the remainder added to the policy's cash value after fees are deducted. Cash value is credited monthly or annually with interest based on increases in a stock index.

Although IUL insurance can be valuable for some people, it is important to understand how it works before buying a policy. It has several pros and cons compared with other forms of life insurance.

How Does IUL Work?

IUL insurance is often marketed as a cash value insurance policy that benefits from tax-free market gains without the risk of losses during a market downturn.

An IUL insurance policy provides permanent coverage as long as premiums are paid, including a death benefit paid to your designated beneficiary or beneficiaries when the insured dies. The policy may also grow in value during your lifetime through its cash value component.

The cash value portion of your policy earns interest based on the performance of an underlying stock market index. For example, returns may be linked to the Standard & Poor's (S&P) 500 composite price index, which tracks the movements of the 500 largest U.S. companies by market capitalization. As the index rises or falls, so does the rate of return on your policy's cash value component.

The insurance company issuing the policy may offer a guaranteed minimum rate of return. There may also be an upper limit, or rate cap, on returns.

IUL insurance is riskier than fixed universal life insurance policies, which offer a guaranteed rate of return. However, it is less risky than variable universal life insurance, which lets you invest directly in mutual funds or other securities.

Benefits of IUL

As with any type of universal life insurance, it is vital to research any prospective company thoroughly to ensure it is among the best universal life insurers currently operating. With that in mind, here are some of the main advantages of including IUL in your financial plan.

Greater Return Potential

These policies use call options (Money Call options) to gain upside exposure to stock indexes without the risk of losses, while whole life insurance and fixed universal life insurance policies provide only a modest interest rate that may not even be guaranteed. Of course, the annual return you see with an IUL policy depends on how well its underlying index performs. Your insurance company may still offer a guaranteed minimum return on your investment.

Greater Flexibility

IUL insurance can provide flexibility in building a policy designed to meet your investment goals. Policyholders can decide how much market risk they want to take, adjust death benefit amounts as needed, and choose from a range of riders that tailor the policy to their needs. For example, you might add a long-term care rider to cover nursing home costs if needed.

Tax-Free Capital Gains

Policyholders do not pay capital gains tax on increases in cash value over time unless they surrender the policy before it matures, while other types of financial accounts may tax capital gains upon withdrawal. This benefit extends to any loans you take against the policy's cash value.
Having an available cash source to borrow against can be appealing if you want to avoid triggering taxes and penalties through an early withdrawal from a 401(k) or IRA.

Unlike a 401(k) or traditional IRA, the cash value accumulated in an indexed universal life insurance policy is not subject to required minimum distributions.

No Impact on Social Security

Social Security benefits can be an important source of retirement income. You can begin receiving benefits as early as age 62 or defer them until age 70. Taking benefits before your full retirement age can reduce your benefit amount, as can working while receiving benefits. Before reaching full retirement age, you may earn only a certain amount each year before benefits are reduced.

Cash value accumulation in an IUL insurance policy does not count toward earnings thresholds, nor do amounts you borrow through a policy loan. You could therefore borrow against your policy to supplement Social Security without reducing your benefit amount.

Death Benefit

IUL insurance, like other types of life insurance, can provide a death benefit for your loved ones. This money can pay funeral and burial expenses, cover outstanding debts such as a mortgage or cosigned student loans, fund children's college costs, or simply pay everyday living expenses. This death benefit can pass to your beneficiaries tax-free.

Drawbacks of Indexed Universal Life Insurance

Critics often point to several drawbacks associated with IUL insurance policies. For example, someone who buys a policy while the market is performing poorly could end up making high premium payments that contribute nothing to cash value. The policy could potentially lapse if premium payments are not made on time during the insured's life, undermining the entire purpose of life insurance.

Other considerations include the following:

a. Limits on Returns

Insurance companies often set maximum participation rates below 100%, and in some cases as low as 25%. In addition, returns from stock indexes are typically capped during good years. These restrictions can limit the actual rate of return credited to your account each year, regardless of how the policy's underlying index performs.

In that case, you may be better off investing directly in the market or considering a variable universal life insurance policy. But it is important to consider your personal risk tolerance and investment goals to ensure either approach aligns with your overall strategy.

b. No Guarantees

Whole life insurance policies often include a guaranteed interest rate with predictable premiums throughout the policy's life. IUL policies, on the other hand, offer index-based returns and have premiums that vary over time.

This means you must be comfortable navigating fluctuating returns while budgeting for potentially higher premiums.


c. Fees

IUL insurance policies may have a wide range of fees and other costs, including:

  • Premium expense charges
  • Administrative expenses
  • Rider costs
  • Fees and commissions
  • Surrender charges

All these fees and costs can reduce the rate of return your policy provides.

That is why it is important to research the best life insurance companies so you understand what you are paying for coverage and what you receive in return.

Pros and Cons of Indexed Universal Life Insurance

Pros

  1. Provides higher returns than other life insurance policies.
  2. Policies can be designed around your 'appetite' for risk.
  3. Allows tax-free capital gains.
  4. IUL does not reduce Social Security benefits.

Cons

  • Returns are capped at a certain level.
  • No guaranteed returns.
  • IUL may have higher fees than other policies.

Indexed Universal Life Insurance vs. Other Life Insurance Policies

Unlike other types of life insurance, an IUL policy's value is linked to a stock market index. This means returns can vary depending on the underlying index's performance.

There are many other types of life insurance policies, explained below.

  • Term life insurance provides a fixed benefit if the policyholder dies within a specified period, generally 10 to 30 years. It is one of the most affordable types of life insurance, as well as the simplest.
  • Whole life insurance is more permanent, with the policy lasting for the policyholder's entire life.
    The policy builds value according to a fixed schedule and has fewer fees than an IUL policy. However, it does not offer the flexibility to adjust premiums.
  • Variable life insurance offers even more flexibility than IUL insurance, which also makes it more complicated.
    A variable policy's cash value may depend on the performance of specific stocks, and its premium may also change.
    For this reason, variable life insurance is considered riskier than other life insurance policies.

Is Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL) a Good Investment?

Although an indexed universal life insurance policy can be a good way to provide for loved ones, it is not an appropriate investment strategy for most people. High premiums and additional charges can make an indexed policy difficult to maintain over the long term, and you may lose the money you have already spent if the policy lapses.

Although this may suit some people, others may be better served by stocks or bonds.


What Makes Up an Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL) Policy?

An indexed universal life insurance policy includes:

  • A death benefit
  • A component linked to a stock market index
  • Cash value that rises or falls depending on that index's performance
  • Potentially higher returns than other forms of life insurance, along with greater risks and additional fees

Is Indexed Universal Life Insurance Better Than a 401(k) Plan?

Indexed universal life insurance and 401(k) plans each have their own advantages. A 401(k) offers more investment choices and may include an employer contribution. An IUL, however, provides a death benefit and additional cash value against which the policyholder can borrow. It also comes with high premiums and charges and, unlike a 401(k), can be canceled if the insured stops paying.


IUL insurance can help meet your family's financial protection needs while also building cash value. However, these policies can be more complex than other types of life insurance and are not necessarily suitable for every investor. Speaking with an experienced life insurance agent or broker can help you decide whether indexed universal life insurance is right for you.

More information:

  1. National Institutes of Health (NIH): “Life Insurance: Ownership and Investment Considerations.”
  2. Internal Revenue Service (IRS). "Hardships, Early Withdrawals and Loans".
  3. U.S. Social Security Administration (SSA.GOV). "Starting Your Retirement Benefits Early".
  4. U.S. Social Security Administration (SSA.GOV). "Receiving Benefits While Working".
  5. Internal Revenue Service (IRS). "Do I Report Proceeds Paid Under a Life Insurance Contract as Taxable Income?"
  6. Article on Progressive.com: "What Is Indexed Universal Life Insurance?"
  7. Article on policyme.com: Universal Life Insurance: A Good Investment Strategy or Bad News?
  8. Finance Strategists at https://financestrategists.com: "Indexed Universal Life vs. 401(k)".