Here for every stage of your life. (855) 436-6552
Partners for Life — Insurance Agency & Financial Services
← Back to articles

Permanent Life Insurance as Supplemental Retirement Income

Life insurance, specifically universal life insurance, could be part of a sound retirement plan. Universal life policies offer investment options that can help you save for retirement. Cash value in a universal life account accumulates tax-free, and retirees sometimes use those funds to bridge the period from retirement until age 70, when they receive the maximum Social Security benefit.

Term Policies and Permanent Policies

One of the main differences is that a term life policy provides coverage for a specified period, while permanent policies are not designed to expire within a normal lifetime. Some routinely end when the insured person turns 100.

Unlike term life insurance, permanent life insurance offers both a death benefit and a savings benefit, the latter funded essentially by the policyholder's premiums. Permanent life policies are more expensive than term life policies because of this cash value component.

Types of Policies

There are only two types of life insurance policies: term or permanent. Term coverage expires after a certain period, while permanent coverage runs for the policyholder's lifetime. Among permanent policies, insurance companies promote a wide variety of policies called "whole life" or "universal life."

Whole life insurance offers a consistent premium and guaranteed cash value accumulation. In exchange, premiums are likely to be much higher than those for term insurance, but the payout is assured. The only risks are that you end up paying more in fees than your return is worth or that the company goes bankrupt.

Universal life insurance offers greater flexibility in premium costs, death benefits, and savings because policies allow policyholders to benefit from a strong stock market. Universal life policies were very popular as retirement income vehicles when first introduced in the 1980s and 1990s.

Loans and Withdrawals

As the cash value in universal life insurance plans accumulates, policyholders can borrow against it. In fact, borrowing is the most tax-advantaged way to use these funds. Life insurance cash value can be accessed during the policyholder's lifetime in two ways: loans and withdrawals. You can access your basis—what you have contributed to the policy—without tax implications. In other words, funds withdrawn from the account generally are not subject to income tax, unlike distributions from traditional IRAs and 401(k) plans.

Although your contributions are not taxed, earnings are subject to ordinary income tax rates unless you take them as a loan. In other words, technically you do not withdraw funds from the insurance policy; you borrow against it. This is no different from taking out a home equity loan against the equity in your house. These life insurance policy loans are not subject to income tax. Although you pay interest on them, you can also use funds from the cash value account to cover interest payments.

Retirement Income

A key benefit, in addition to the life insurance component, is that you can use your universal life policy for income after retirement. The cash value account within an insurance policy accumulates tax-free. Some people use their life insurance policy's cash value to bridge the gap between [the year of their] retirement and age 70, when they can receive the highest Social Security benefit.

Generally, the longer you allow your cash value life insurance policy to grow, the better. A good rule of thumb is to wait at least 15 years after buying a policy before beginning to take distributions.

Cash Value

Cash value earnings are an important component of maintaining the policy, not just the premiums you pay. Often, with universal life policies, the premium amount varies according to the performance of the policy's investment portion. In other words, the policy's cash value is not just your income source; it is there to help pay for the insurance, supplementing or even covering your premiums entirely.

Cash value earnings are especially important during periods when the policyholder takes a loan against the policy's cash value. If you take out too much money and the policy's cost exceeds its cash value, it is similar to being underwater. If your insurance policy lapses, you would not only lose your death benefit; all funds you borrowed or withdrew from the policy would be considered taxable income.

How Much Should You Withdraw?

How do you know how much you can safely withdraw before or after retirement? When you purchase one of these policies, the terms are set out in what the insurance industry calls an illustration . This document highlights the assumptions used to calculate your expected cash value, monthly interest rate, and other key policy components.

Unrealistically optimistic illustrations left many early universal life policyholders underwater, often just when they were counting on their assets to help them in retirement.

In an effort to ensure more realistic illustrations, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners adopted a new actuarial guideline, AG 49, in 2015 to give insurance companies a more uniform method for calculating maximum illustrated rates for equity-indexed universal life (IUL) insurance products.

An updated version, AG49-A, was implemented in late November 2020.

Life Insurance as Part of Your Retirement Plan

You can use your universal life policy to strengthen your income in retirement. The cash value account within an insurance policy accumulates tax-free. Retirees can use those funds from the time they retire until age 70, when they receive the highest Social Security benefit. Some let their policy mature and then cash it in to receive the maximum benefit. And borrowing against the cash value is the most tax-advantaged way to use these funds.

When Is It Safe to Withdraw Funds?

This is complicated, and consulting your agent may be wise. The policy terms are set out in the insurance illustration, which highlights the assumptions used to calculate your expected cash value and other policy details. Those assumptions came into question after some clients failed to accumulate funds as expected. To ensure more realistic illustrations, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners adopted actuarial guidelines in 2015 that give insurers a uniform method for calculating maximum illustrated rates. Still, as of 2019, insurance regulators were questioning how accurate and effective those guidelines were.

Every life insurance plan has pros and cons. The best way to determine which is best for you is to define your goals. If your main goal is to ensure your loved ones are well cared for after you are gone, term life insurance could be the most cost-effective choice. But if you hope to use your life insurance policy to help fund retirement, permanent life is a better option.

Whether you should purchase whole life or universal life insurance depends largely on your financial situation and risk tolerance. In any case, if your life insurance policy was written years ago and has not had a thorough review recently, it may be time to visit your insurance agent.